BNB $590.05 -0.77%
XRP $0.955114 -1.10%
ETH $1,814.50 -0.53%
BTC $64,500.47 -0.98%
BNB $590.05 -0.77%
XRP $0.955114 -1.10%
ETH $1,814.50 -0.53%
BTC $64,500.47 -0.98%
BREAKING
Altcoins News

Juicebox V6 tests expose four skipped-payment paths under Glamsterdam rules

Juicebox V6 tests show four skipped-payment paths under Ethereum Glamsterdam rules

Community Trust ScoreVerified

85%
Real
Verified41 votes
Updated 5 minutes ago

Developer mejango published simulations of Juicebox V6 contracts on the Sepolia test network that revealed four specific paths where transactions succeed while internal payments fail. The tests were conducted using the proposed rules for the Ethereum Glamsterdam upgrade, specifically EIP-8037 and EIP-8038.

As of 04:33 UTC, Ethereum traded at $1,826, +0.2% over 24 hours, with $11.3 billion in 24-hour volume.

Four Failure Paths Identified

The simulations utilized deployed contract code via the eth_simulateV1 method. In each scenario, a fresh project was launched and funded within the simulation environment. The developer tested payment paths across different transaction gas limits, pinning each scenario to a specific blockchain block to ensure reproducibility.

Advertisement

The results identified four distinct outcomes where the outer transaction completed successfully but an internal payment was skipped. In one instance, a buyer retained an NFT while the associated payment to another project failed to execute. Another scenario showed a cash-out completing while a 2.5% fee was effectively forgiven. A third outcome involved a reserved-token distribution finishing despite a failed cross-project payment, resulting in the beneficiary receiving raw tokens.

For the cash-out test, the developer sampled gas limits ranging from a lower bound of 679,622 to an upper bound of 817,622. These specific parameters were used to isolate the conditions under which the payment failure occurred.

Mechanism and Mainnet Comparison

The underlying failure mechanism occurs when an internal payment that writes fresh storage runs out of gas before the outer transaction concludes. The contract’s try/catch error handling absorbs this internal failure, allowing the surrounding operation to finish without reverting the entire transaction. This behavior is distinct from a standard transaction failure where the entire operation is rolled back.

Comparison runs on the Ethereum mainnet showed different results. Across the sampled ranges for all four paths, mainnet runs resulted in either complete transaction failures or complete delivery of payments. No skipped-payment band was reported in the mainnet comparison, indicating that the issue is specific to the proposed cost changes in the Glamsterdam upgrade.

Foundation Discussion and Next Steps

The Ethereum Foundation’s update on Nov. 9 recommended reviewing public audit findings before deciding on specification changes or the schedule for the Hoodi testnet. No decision was precommitted in that update. The Foundation listed Nov. 19 for a discussion of the findings and possible next steps.

On Nov. 13, mejango asked whether the impacts of these skipped payments fall within the Ethereum Foundation’s tolerance for breaking changes. The developer linked the answer to confidence in building immutable applications whose deployed code cannot be changed in place. The findings are intended to inform the execution-layer discussion scheduled for Thursday, Nov. 16.

The agenda for the Nov. 16 testing call explicitly lists Juicebox’s compatibility concerns and proofs of concept. These tests advance a broader compatibility warning that emerged in early November. The proposed changes in EIP-8037 aim to support more throughput while controlling resource demands by introducing higher costs for creating persistent blockchain data and separate accounting for state creation and execution. EIP-8038 updates the costs of accessing and writing state.

Community Trust IndexHigh Confidence
85%
Real
Real85%15%Fake
41 community signals

Bruce Buterin

Bruce Buterin is an American crypto analyst passionate about the evolution of Web3, crypto ETFs, and Ethereum innovations. Based in Miami, he closely follows market movements and regularly publishes in-depth insights on DeFi trends, emerging altcoins, and asset tokenization. With a mix of technical expertise and accessible language, Bruce makes the blockchain ecosystem clear and engaging for both enthusiasts and investors. Specialties: Ethereum, DeFi, NFTs, U.S. regulation, Layer 2 innovations.

Advertisement

Related Stories