Home Altcoins News Legal Expert Reveals XRP’s Varied Legal Status: California vs. New York

Legal Expert Reveals XRP’s Varied Legal Status: California vs. New York


Development concerning the legal status of XRP, prominent attorney Fred Rispoli has sparked controversy by suggesting that the cryptocurrency could potentially be classified as a security in California while being exempt from such categorization in New York. This assertion comes on the heels of a recent judicial decision that has reignited debates over the regulatory framework surrounding digital assets like XRP.

The focal point of this debate stems from the Zakinov civil securities lawsuit against Ripple, which alleged that Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse violated securities laws during the 2017 XRP offering. In a pivotal ruling delivered by Judge Phyllis Hamilton, four claims against Ripple were dismissed, including the failure to register with the SEC. However, one crucial aspect remains unsettled: whether XRP was indeed offered and sold as a security.

Ripple’s legal team, led by its counsel, referenced the precedent set by Judge Analisa Torres in a separate SEC lawsuit. Judge Torres had reasoned that Ripple’s programmatic sales of XRP on digital exchanges did not meet the criteria of a security under the Howey test. This test evaluates whether a transaction involves an investment contract, particularly focusing on expectations of profit derived from the efforts of others.

Contrary to Judge Torres’ reasoning, Judge Hamilton decided that this particular issue would be left to a jury to decide, indicating a departure from previous judicial interpretations. This decision echoes similar disagreements seen in previous rulings across different jurisdictions, highlighting the lack of consensus in defining XRP’s legal status.

Attorney Fred Rispoli emphasized the need for federal legislation to establish clear guidelines applicable nationwide. He underscored the current disparity where XRP is considered a non-security in New York but could potentially be categorized as a security in California. Rispoli argued that without federal intervention, such discrepancies could hinder the growth and adoption of cryptocurrencies by creating legal uncertainty.

Meanwhile, Ripple’s Chief Legal Officer Stuart Alderoty expressed confidence in the validity of Judge Torres’ reasoning despite the recent judicial divergence. Alderoty emphasized that Judge Torres’ assessment remains pivotal in shaping Ripple’s legal strategy moving forward.

The ongoing debate surrounding XRP’s regulatory classification underscores broader challenges faced by the cryptocurrency industry. With varying interpretations across state lines and different judicial circuits, stakeholders are calling for cohesive federal legislation to provide uniformity and clarity. Such legislation would not only benefit market participants and investors but also contribute to a more robust regulatory framework capable of accommodating technological innovation.

As the legal landscape continues to evolve, the outcome of the Zakinov case and similar legal challenges will likely have profound implications for the future of cryptocurrencies in the United States. Advocates for the crypto industry hope that these developments will spur constructive dialogue towards achieving regulatory certainty that fosters innovation while safeguarding investor interests.

In conclusion, while XRP’s status as a security remains uncertain in the eyes of the law, the ongoing legal battles and judicial interpretations underscore the pressing need for regulatory clarity on a federal level. Until then, stakeholders across the cryptocurrency ecosystem will navigate a complex and evolving regulatory environment shaped by judicial decisions and legislative initiatives.

Read more about:
Share on


Mike T, an accomplished crypto journalist, has been captivating audiences with her in-depth analysis and insightful reporting on the ever-evolving blockchain and cryptocurrency landscape. With a keen eye for market trends and a talent for breaking down complex concepts, Mike's work has become essential reading for both crypto enthusiasts and newcomers alike. Appreciate the work? Send a tip to: 0x4C6D67705aF449f0C0102D4C7C693ad4A64926e9

Crypto newsletter

Get the latest Crypto & Blockchain News in your inbox.

By clicking Subscribe, you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Get the latest updates from our Telegram channel.

Telegram Icon Join Now ×