Community Trust ScoreVerified
US District Judge Jessica Clarke cleared Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno on Nov. 16, rejecting wire fraud and related conspiracy charges tied to a $25 million Ethereum maximum extractable value (MEV) exploit. The judge’s 46-page opinion concluded that prosecutors did not prove a material misrepresentation, a key element of the alleged fraud.
More coverage is filed under Scams.
As of 11:50 UTC, Ethereum traded at $1,817, +0.6% over 24 hours, with $11.5 billion in 24-hour volume.
Bot manipulation and legal limits
The brothers carried out the scheme in 2023 by deploying lure transactions intended to trigger sandwich-trading bots. These bots attempt to profit by positioning transactions before and after a target trade, often resulting in a worse execution price for the original trader. By exploiting a vulnerability in relay code, the defendants extracted approximately $25 million in just 12 seconds.
Judge Clarke determined that interfering with the intended design of MEV-Boost did not constitute a material misrepresentation. The court distinguished the case from prior spoofing precedents, noting that the lure transactions actually executed and were not placed on a regulated market. The ruling does not create a universal requirement for wire fraud to occur on a regulated exchange, nor does it declare all forms of MEV extraction lawful.
Tokenized venue disclosures
While the criminal case ended in acquittal, regulatory attention has shifted to how tokenized securities venues manage MEV risks. In a March 30 letter, the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association (SIFMA) argued that exposing pending trades to sandwiching and front-running conflicts with securities-market expectations. SIFMA urged the adoption of technical protections or fair-sequencing rules when automated market makers (AMMs) handle securities.
An AMM allows participants to trade against assets in a pool using software-defined pricing. The SEC issued an order on Sept. 17 providing temporary, conditional relief from the exchange definition for qualifying tokenized National Market System stock venues that use permissioned AMM pools. Certain liquidity providers trading proprietary capital received separate relief from the dealer definition until Sept. 17, 2031. The order retains antifraud and antimanipulation provisions, including Exchange Act Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5.
Four filers face scrutiny
The SEC’s order requires venues to describe their MEV policies or state that they have none. They must also disclose material risks, explain mitigation and compensation arrangements, and detail trading-abuse monitoring. The SEC’s public list, reviewed on Nov. 16, includes four notice filers with submission dates ranging from TSV LLC’s Sept. 23 notice to Formation Securities’ Nov. 9 filing.
TSV LLC’s notice states that Canton’s architecture generally avoids broadcasting readable pending transaction contents to unrelated participants. The company acknowledges risks of information leakage, sequencing, compromised infrastructure, and collusion. TSV LLC notes it does not intend to prevent lawful post-execution arbitrage or price alignment that avoids misuse of confidential information. Participants generally should not expect compensation for market or impermanent losses, compromised systems, or losses caused by unaffiliated third parties, unless expressly agreed otherwise or required by law.
OKXICE’s Nov. 5 notice disclosed that it has no policies and procedures designed to address MEV. The company stated that its features mitigate, rather than eliminate, MEV risk. OKXICE’s planned pools use Uniswap v4 on XLayer, where the sequencer generally orders transactions according to offered network fees. Perpetuals.com’s notice proposes generally first-in, first-out sequencing with priority for trading-halt instructions. Its affiliated sequencer would receive nonpublic transaction information. Perpetuals.com stated that it has no established compensation policy for the risks described in its notice. The October notice describes safeguards that were not fully implemented and surveillance intended to precede trading.
Formation Securities’ notice describes planned safeguards for its Solana venue. The company specifically excludes compensation for lost or compromised private keys or wallets.


