BNB $571.66 -1.56%
XRP $0.952386 -0.90%
ETH $1,732.07 -2.23%
BTC $61,499.91 -1.88%
BNB $571.66 -1.56%
XRP $0.952386 -0.90%
ETH $1,732.07 -2.23%
BTC $61,499.91 -1.88%
BREAKING
stable coins

Tether disputes S&P lowest USDT score

Tether Defies S&P's Lowest USDT Stability Score With 'Big Short' Reference

Community Trust ScoreVerified

84%
Real
Verified31 votes
Updated 1 minute ago

S&P Global Ratings assigned a 5, the lowest score on its five-point scale, to the USDT stablecoin’s ability to maintain its dollar peg on November 18. The agency defined this rating as weak, marking no change from the November 2025 evaluation that first downgraded the asset. Tether dismissed the assessment, attributing the negative outlook to flaws in S&P’s evaluation framework rather than the composition of its own reserves.

As of 05:48 UTC, Tether traded at $0.9992, -0.0% over 24 hours, with $51.9 billion in 24-hour volume.

Reserve Composition and Risk Exposure

The assessment highlights higher-risk assets and transparency issues as the primary factors behind the low score. As of September 30, holdings categorized as higher-risk—including Bitcoin, gold, public equities, secured loans, and corporate bonds—accounted for approximately 28% of USDT in circulation. This figure represents an increase from 24% recorded a year earlier. S&P warned that a significant decline in the value of these specific holdings could result in USDT being undercollateralized. The agency noted that it could not lower the score further because 5 represents the bottom of its assessment scale. Despite assigning the lowest rating, S&P acknowledged that USDT had demonstrated a strong record of price stability, particularly over the previous 12 months.

Regulatory Framework and Audit Status

Tether relocated its operations to El Salvador in January 2025. The country’s National Commission of Digital Assets mandates that 70% of reserves be held in assets liquidatable within 30 days. S&P described this regulatory framework as broad, permitting Bitcoin, gold, and loans to qualify as eligible assets. The agency pointed out that El Salvador does not require the segregation of reserve assets from the issuer’s other holdings, a contrast with regulators in the United States and Europe, who generally expect stronger safeguards regarding asset segregation. Tether’s September 30 reserve report, attested by BDO, listed approximately $191.5 billion in assets against $183.5 billion in liabilities, resulting in roughly $7.95 billion in excess assets. The reports do not identify the custodians or counterparties holding these assets, and Tether publishes attestations quarterly, whereas some competing stablecoin issuers provide monthly updates.

In August 2026, KPMG issued an unqualified opinion on Tether’s 2025 accounts, which Tether described as its first full independent audit. However, S&P stated that the audited financial statements and the auditor’s report had not been published. In response to the initial 2025 downgrade, CEO Paolo Ardoino criticized the agency on X, a stance maintained in the latest rebuttal. Tether referenced the film ‘The Big Short’ in its response, with Ardoino stating that the company wore its criticism with pride.

Community Trust IndexHigh Confidence
84%
Real
Real84%16%Fake
31 community signals

Sydney TheCMO

Sydney has 20+ years commercial experience and has spent the last 10 years working in the online marketing arena and was the CMO for a large FX brokerage.

Advertisement

Related Stories