Peter Schiff, a long-time Bitcoin skeptic, has once again taken to social media to voice his criticism of the U.S. government’s decision to establish a Bitcoin reserve, an idea proposed by former President Donald Trump. Schiff, a well-known advocate for gold, argued that the government would have been better off purchasing gold instead of Bitcoin, especially given the cryptocurrency’s recent price volatility.

Schiff Doubles Down on Gold Argument

Schiff’s criticism comes at a time when Bitcoin’s price has been struggling amid broader concerns about a potential U.S. recession. The cryptocurrency, which had been experiencing some recovery, faced downward pressure as economic uncertainty lingered.

Taking to X (formerly Twitter), Schiff pointed out that the Bitcoin held in Trump’s newly established Strategic Bitcoin Reserve had declined in value by over 12% since its inception. He argued that if the U.S. government had sold its Bitcoin holdings and used the funds to purchase gold, the nation would now be in a better position financially.

“A month ago on Mar. 6th, Trump established the Strategic Bitcoin Reserve,” Schiff wrote. “So far, the value of the Bitcoin held in that reserve has declined by over 12%. Had the U.S. sold it and added to our gold reserve, not only would we have avoided that loss, but we would now have a 2% gain.”

Gold: A Safe Haven in Turbulent Times

Schiff’s argument centers around the idea that gold is a safer investment during periods of economic instability. He noted that while Bitcoin has been subject to sharp price fluctuations, gold has consistently proven to be a reliable hedge against inflation and market downturns.

The recent volatility in Bitcoin’s price only added weight to Schiff’s position. Bitcoin has struggled to maintain a steady upward trend, as concerns about a potential U.S. recession continue to affect investor confidence. Schiff emphasized that gold, unlike Bitcoin, has the stability needed to withstand such economic turbulence.

Critics Respond to Schiff’s Criticism

However, Schiff’s comments were met with strong rebuttals from the cryptocurrency community. One prominent critic, going by the name “The Bitcoin Therapist” on X, pointed out that Schiff’s long-standing support for gold had led to poor returns over the past 15 years. The critic claimed that Schiff’s argument was “cherry-picking” and that Bitcoin remained a more favorable investment despite recent market corrections.

“You literally held gold and had the absolute worst ROI over a 15-year period only to finally be right in 2024-2025,” the user posted. “Cherry-picking is retarded. Bitcoin is and always will be a more favorable investment.”

Schiff’s critics also dismissed his recession warnings, arguing that the economy might not be as fragile as he suggests. Nevertheless, Schiff persisted in his pessimistic outlook, warning that U.S. equities were dangerously overvalued, and the potential for a severe recession in 2025 remained high.

Schiff’s Recession Warnings and the Role of the Federal Reserve

Schiff has long warned of an impending economic downturn and remains steadfast in his belief that the U.S. is heading toward a recession. He pointed to Polymarket, a predictions platform, which currently assigns a 65% probability to a U.S. recession in 2025. Schiff’s stance remains critical of the Federal Reserve, which he believes is delaying the inevitable by keeping interest rates artificially low.

“Only the Federal Reserve can delay the inevitable,” Schiff quipped in a sarcastic response to a user who downplayed the chances of a downturn.

Bitcoin’s Recent Performance Amid Market Volatility

Meanwhile, Bitcoin’s price has shown signs of recovery. At the time of writing, Bitcoin was trading above $81,000 after a 7% increase, offering a glimmer of hope to investors who had been worried about the cryptocurrency’s recent instability. However, the inconsistent price action has done little to ease broader concerns about market uncertainty.

Conclusion: Schiff’s Criticism and the Broader Economic Landscape

While Peter Schiff’s criticism of Trump’s Bitcoin Reserve proposal has fueled a lively debate, it highlights the ongoing tension between traditional safe-haven assets like gold and the emerging role of cryptocurrencies in global financial markets. As Bitcoin’s volatility continues to impact investor sentiment, Schiff’s unwavering belief in gold as a hedge against economic uncertainty only strengthens his position.

Despite the recent market recovery, both Bitcoin and traditional financial markets remain highly sensitive to global economic conditions. Whether Schiff’s warnings about a recession come to pass will ultimately depend on the trajectory of the U.S. economy and the Federal Reserve’s actions in the coming months.